High Energy Costs and Carbon Taxes Threaten UK’s Chemical Industry

January 13, 2025

The chemical industry in the UK is facing a crisis, with high energy prices and stringent carbon taxes leading to the closure of key facilities. Sir Jim Ratcliffe, chair of Ineos, has voiced his concerns over the impact of these factors on the sector, highlighting the recent shutdown of Ineos’ last remaining synthetic ethanol plant at Grangemouth.

The Impact of Rising Energy Costs

Escalating Energy Prices

Over the past five years, energy costs in the UK have doubled, creating a significant competitive disadvantage for the chemical industry. Ratcliffe points out that UK energy prices are now five times higher than those in the US, making it nearly impossible for UK-based chemical manufacturers to compete on a global scale. The financial strain resulting from these escalating energy rates has led to the closure of ten large chemical complexes in the UK over recent years, and worryingly, there have been no new constructions in this field within a generation.

The severe price imbalance not only places British manufacturers in a precarious position but also jeopardizes the nation’s industrial infrastructure. Ratcliffe emphasizes that such a disparity in energy costs is unsustainable and detrimental to the sector’s long-term viability. The soaring prices are compounded by the rising costs of raw materials and labor, exacerbating the overall expense burden on chemical makers. Consequently, the industry struggles to maintain profitability and operational efficiency against more favorably positioned competitors. This financial reality underscores the dire need for intervention and policy adjustments to stabilize the situation and sustain the sector’s growth.

Consequences for the Grangemouth Plant

The Grangemouth synthetic ethanol plant, once a major producer of synthetic alcohol for pharmaceutical manufacturing, has been forced to close due to these unsustainable energy costs. This facility had achieved remarkable operational efficiency over its 40-year lifetime, producing synthetic alcohol equivalent to 25 billion bottles of Scottish whisky. The recent closure has had a rippling effect on the local and broader economy, directly leading to the loss of several hundred jobs and necessitating imports to meet the consistent demand for synthetic ethanol products.

The fallout from the plant’s cessation is far-reaching, impacting various stakeholders from direct employees to ancillary service providers. Ineos managed to redeploy many of its workers internally within its chemicals business at Grangemouth, mitigating some of the immediate job loss impacts. Nonetheless, the net loss of 80 positions underscores the broader economic challenge. In addition to direct employment effects, the plant’s shutdown is anticipated to affect over 500 indirect roles, reflecting a substantial contraction in economic activity linked to this industrial hub.

The Role of Carbon Taxes

Stringent Carbon Regulations

In addition to high energy costs, stringent carbon regulations have further burdened the chemical industry. Ratcliffe emphasizes that these regulations have made it increasingly challenging for the sector to maintain viability and competitiveness. The combined weight of escalating energy prices and rigorous carbon taxes has generated a considerable cost differential for processes like distilling and purifying ethanol, approximately amounting to 10% of its sales price. This additional financial strain manifests in higher operational expenditures and discomforting uncertainties in financial planning for chemical manufacturers.

The stringent regulation framework places UK-based chemical producers at a global disadvantage, where many competitor nations do not impose similarly prohibitive carbon schemes. This harsh regulatory climate catalyzes a decline in local manufacturing capabilities, thereby increasing dependency on imports. Such reliance not only weakens domestic production but also undermines the country’s industrial resilience and strategic autonomy in vital sectors like pharmaceuticals and renewable energies.

Impact on Employment and Economy

The closure of the Grangemouth plant has led to a net job loss of 80 positions, despite Ineos’ efforts to redeploy its direct employees within its chemicals business. The broader economic impact is significant, potentially affecting over 500 indirect roles across various connected sectors. This development adds to the worrying trend of industrial decline, following the announcement by Petroineos, a joint venture between PetroChina and Ineos, to shut down its oil refinery at Grangemouth by the second quarter of 2025, which will result in a further loss of 400 jobs.

This economic contraction not only endangers the livelihoods of thousands of workers and their families but also threatens the economic health of regions dependent on this industrial activity. As major employers retract operations, the potential destabilization could undermine local economies and erode community welfare. The compound effect of job losses and logistics shifts signifies a troubling trajectory for industrial zones, underlining the critical need for intervention and strategic support to mitigate the long-term impacts on the UK’s labor market and regional economies.

Regional Disparities and Competitive Imbalance

Energy Cost Disparities

Given the regional disparities in energy costs within the UK, Ratcliffe highlights significant competitive imbalances that hamper the chemical industry’s performance. Some areas benefit from energy rates five to ten times lower than others depending on their infrastructure and access to resources. This inconsistency complicates the business planning process for manufacturers and exacerbates the challenges of maintaining competitive operations across different geographic areas. This disparity undercuts the ability to strategize uniformly across regions, creating pockets of inefficiency and heightened costs.

Many competitor countries outside the UK and the EU do not impose carbon reduction trading schemes or taxes, giving them a marked edge over UK manufacturers. This broader competitive imbalance intensifies the financial and operational pressures faced by the domestic chemical industry, leading to dwindling local production and increased challenges in maintaining a sustainable business model. The combined effect of varying regional energy costs and lenient international carbon policies puts UK-based manufacturers at an inherent disadvantage.

Shifting Production and Emissions

Ratcliffe argues that deindustrializing the UK does not contribute to global environmental goals effectively because it merely shifts production and emissions to other locations with less stringent regulations. This outsourcing of industrial activity often leads to higher net emissions and less efficient production processes globally, counteracting the intended environmental benefits of domestic carbon reductions. He advocates for sustaining high-quality manufacturing facilities and preserving associated jobs, particularly in economically vulnerable regions like northern UK.

An unbalanced focus on regulatory rigor over practical support poses a threat to the industrial ecosystem. Ratcliffe suggests that a nuanced balance supporting both sustainability and operational viability should guide future policies. These conditions are unsustainable and risk dismantling a significant industry, necessitating decisive measures to support the sector while advancing environmental objectives. The UK must develop and implement policies that promote both environmental and economic sustainability, addressing these complex challenges comprehensively.

Calls for Government Action

Proposed Measures

To address these challenges, Ratcliffe calls upon the UK government to implement several measures aimed at stabilizing and revitalizing the chemical industry. He proposes the adoption of an energy policy that ensures globally competitive pricing for crucial resources such as natural gas and hydrogen. This step would help align UK energy costs more closely with those of international competitors, mitigating the current price disadvantage. Additionally, Ratcliffe emphasizes the need for an Emissions Trading Scheme that equally supports industrial performance and decarbonization efforts, fostering a balanced approach to environmental regulations.

Moreover, he advocates for a trade policy that bolsters UK manufacturing in domestic markets without creating incentives for imports. Such a strategy would aim to enhance local production capabilities and reduce dependency on international suppliers, strengthening the domestic manufacturing base. These coordinated efforts are critical to ensuring that the chemical sector can navigate the financial and regulatory pressures it currently faces while continuing to innovate and contribute to the UK’s economic prosperity.

Government Response

In response to Ineos’ announcement, a UK Government spokesperson expressed disappointment, acknowledging the valid concerns it raises for workers and their families. The spokesperson criticized the lack of a coherent industrial strategy over the past fourteen years, attributing the chemical industry’s current predicament to this strategic oversight. They underscored recent initiatives aimed at addressing these issues, including a significant £100 million investment designed to support the local economy and generate job opportunities.

Among these efforts is Project Willow, a forward-thinking initiative exploring sustainable industrial futures for the wider Grangemouth site. This project signals a commitment to fostering long-term industrial growth while transitioning towards environmentally sustainable practices. The government spokesperson emphasized that despite the lack of prior support plans, these new measures represent proactive steps towards revitalizing the industrial landscape and securing economic stability for affected communities.

Scottish Government’s Commitment

Support for Grangemouth Industrial Cluster

A representative from the Scottish Government reiterated their unwavering commitment to securing a sustainable future for the Grangemouth industrial cluster, which includes Ineos’ petrochemicals business. They recognized the significant contributions this business makes to the Scottish economy, particularly within the plastics sector. The impact on the highly skilled workforce is also acknowledged, emphasizing the importance of safeguarding these valuable jobs. These industrial activities are vital to the region’s economic health, facilitating substantial contributions to national and local wealth.

The Scottish Government’s initiatives aim to create synergies between economic requirements and sustainable development goals, ensuring that the industrial cluster remains resilient and adaptive. This multifaceted approach seeks to leverage existing strengths while paving the way for future growth and innovations in low-carbon industries. They stressed the importance of taking strategic actions that align immediate economic needs with long-term environmental objectives, thereby enhancing the resilience of the regional economy.

Transition to Low-Carbon Projects

The chemical industry in the UK is currently grappling with a severe crisis due to soaring energy prices and stringent carbon taxes. These factors are forcing the shutdown of critical facilities, threatening the sector’s viability. Sir Jim Ratcliffe, chairman of Ineos, has expressed significant concerns regarding the detrimental impact of these challenges on the chemical industry. One example he cited is the recent shutdown of Ineos’ last remaining synthetic ethanol plant located at Grangemouth, a key facility for the company. The closure not only reflects the intense pressure the industry is under but also highlights broader issues affecting the UK’s chemical sector. Ratcliffe’s comments underline the urgent need for a comprehensive strategy to address these economic and regulatory challenges, which are jeopardizing the operational capabilities and competitiveness of the industry. Without immediate and effective intervention, the UK’s chemical industry risks losing its standing on the global stage, with far-reaching economic implications.

Subscribe to our weekly news digest.

Join now and become a part of our fast-growing community.

Invalid Email Address
Thanks for Subscribing!
We'll be sending you our best soon!
Something went wrong, please try again later